Disclaimer - We are not Elder Care Lawyers. Get an Elder Care Lawyer PLEASE!!
See http://www.naela.org/
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE BASIC RULES OF NURSING HOME MEDICAID ELIGIBILITY
Introduction For all practical purposes, in the United States the only
"insurance" plan for long-term institutional care is Medicaid. Medicare only
pays for approximately seven percent (7%) of skilled nursing care in the United
States.
Long term care insurance which is designed specifically to pay for these
costs, although a wise financial investment for many people, may be unavailable
or too costly for others. The result is that most people pay out of their own
pockets for long-term care until they become eligible for Medicaid.
While Medicare is an entitlement program, Medicaid is a form of welfare -- or
at least that's how it began. So to be eligible, you must become "impoverished"
under the program's guidelines. Despite the costs, there are advantages to
paying privately for nursing home care.
The foremost is that by paying privately an individual is more likely to gain
entrance to a better quality facility. The obvious disadvantage is the expense.
In New York, nursing home fees average $6,000 - $12,000 a month.
Without proper planning, nursing home residents can lose the bulk of their
savings.
For many individuals, the object of long-term care planning is to protect
savings (by avoiding paying them to a nursing home) while simultaneously
qualifying for nursing home Medicaid benefits.
This can be done within the following rules of Medicaid eligibility.
The Asset Rules
The basic rule of nursing home Medicaid eligibility is that an applicant,
whether single or married, may have no more than $3,950 (effective 1/1/04) in
"countable" assets in his or her name.
"Countable" assets generally include all belongings except for
(1) personal possessions, such as clothing, furniture, and jewelry,
(2) one motor vehicle,
(3) the applicant's principal residence, and
(4) assets that are considered inaccessible for one reason or another.
The applicant's home will not be considered a countable asset and, therefore,
will not be counted against the asset limits for Medicaid eligibility purposes
as long as the nursing home resident intends to return home or his or her spouse
or other dependent relatives live there.
As a result, for all practical purposes nursing home residents do not have to
sell their homes in order to qualify for Medicaid.
The Transfer Penalty
The other major rule of Medicaid eligibility is the penalty for transferring
assets. If an applicant (or his or her spouse) transfers assets, he or she will
be ineligible for Medicaid for a period of time beginning on the date of the
transfer.
The actual number of months of ineligibility is determined by dividing the
amount transferred by a regional monthly nursing home rate as determined by the
New York State Department of Health ("DOH").
- For example, if an applicant made gifts totaling $60,000 and assuming
the regional monthly nursing home rate is $6,000, he or she would be
ineligible for Medicaid for 10 months ($60,000 ÷ $6,000 = 10). Another way
to look at this is that for every $6,000 transferred, an applicant will be
ineligible for nursing home Medicaid benefits for one month. There is
generally no cap on the period of ineligibility.
- So, for instance, the period of ineligibility for the transfer of
property worth $420,000 is 70 months ($420,000 ÷ $6,000 = 70).
- However, the DOH may only consider transfers made during the 36-month
period (60 months in the case of transfers to trusts) preceding an
application for Medicaid, the "look-back" period. Effectively, then, there
is a 36-month cap (60 month cap for transfers to trusts) on periods of
ineligibility resulting from transfers assuming an individual does not apply
for Medicaid prior to the expiration of the look-back period.
- Exceptions To The Transfer Penalty Transferring assets to certain
recipients will not trigger a period of Medicaid ineligibility.
- These exempt recipients include: (1) a spouse (or anyone else for the
spouse's benefit) (2) a blind or disabled child (3) a trust for the benefit
of a disabled individual under age 65 (even for the benefit of the applicant
under certain circumstances)
- Special rules apply with respect to the transfer of a home. In addition
to being able to make the transfers without penalty to one's spouse or blind
or disabled child, or into trust for other disabled beneficiaries, the
applicant may freely transfer his or her home to:
- (1) a child under age 21 (2) a sibling who has lived in the home during
the year preceding the applicant's institutionalization and who already
holds an equity interest in the home (3) a "caretaker child," who is defined
as a child of the applicant who lived in the house for at least two years
prior to the applicant's institutionalization and who during that period
provided such care that the applicant did not need to move to a nursing home
Estate Recovery
The state has the right to recover whatever benefits it paid for the care of
the Medicaid recipient from his or her probate estate.
Given the rules for Medicaid eligibility, the only property of substantial
value that a Medicaid recipient is likely to own at death is his or her home.
Under current law, the state may make a claim against the decedent's home only
if it is in his or her probate estate.
NOTE: Property that is jointly owned, in a life estate, or in a
trust is not included in the probate estate and thus escapes estate recovery.
Treatment of Income
When a nursing home resident becomes eligible for Medicaid, all of his or her
income, less certain deductions, must be paid to the nursing home.
The deductions include a $50-a-month personal needs allowance, a deduction
for any uncovered medical costs (including medical insurance premiums), and, in
the case of a married applicant, an allowance he or she must pay to the spouse
that continues to live at home.
Spousal Protections
Assets Medicaid law provides for special protections for the spouse of a
nursing home resident, known in the law as the "community" spouse.
Under the general rule, the spouse of a married applicant is permitted
to keep the greater of $74,820 of assets or one-half of the couple's combined
assets (as of the date of institutionalization) up to $92,760.
So, for example, if a couple owns $50,000 in countable assets on the date the
applicant enters the hospital, he or she will be eligible for Medicaid
immediately and the at-home spouse would be able to keep the entire $50,000.
If the couple owned $300,000 in assets, the spouse in need of care would not
become eligible until their savings were reduced to $96,710 ($3,950 for the
nursing home spouse plus a maximum of $92,760 for the community spouse).
Income
The income of the community spouse will generally continue undisturbed and he
or she will not have to use his or her income to support the nursing home spouse
receiving Medicaid benefits.
In some cases, the community spouse is also entitled to share in all or a
portion of the monthly income of the nursing home spouse.
The DOH determines an income floor for the community spouse, known as
the minimum monthly maintenance needs allowance, or MMMNA, which, for
2004, is $2,319/month.
(Where the community spouse can show hardship, the DSS may award a larger
MMMNA, but only after an appeal to fair hearing.)
If the community spouse's own income falls below his or her MMMNA, the
shortfall can be made up from the nursing home spouse's income.
If the community spouse’s own income exceeds his or her MMMNA, the DOH
requests that he/she contribute 25% of the excess to the care of the nursing
home spouse.
If the community spouse refuses to contribute, the nursing home spouse
continues to qualify for Medicaid but the DOH, based on the particular
circumstance, may sue the community spouse for that contribution.
Increased Resource Allowance Community spouses whose incomes are less than
their MMMNAs even after considering the income of the nursing home spouse, may
petition the DOH for an increase in the standard resource allowance so that
these additional funds may be invested in order to generate income to make up
the shortfall.
Given current low rates of return, this often can permit the community spouse
to retain a substantial level of savings.
Unfortunately, the DOH may not award an increased resource allowance upon
application.
The intake worker must award the standard allowance described above and the
applicant must appeal the determination to a fair hearing.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Medicaid Rules for Long Term Care
When it was first created in 1965, Medicaid would only pay for nursing home
care for recipients over the age of 65.
But allowances were made in the legislation for exceptions or "waivers" to
the nursing home coverage. In recent years, many states have applied for waivers
to allow their state programs to pay for care in assisted living or at home.
These waiver slots are typically administered by the local area agencies on
aging. As a rule, the vast majority of elderly Medicaid recipients are still
receiving their care in nursing homes.
Financial Eligibility Rules Financial eligibility for Medicaid nursing home
and community waivers requires the recipient to have less than $2,000 in
resources. ($3,000 if a couple needs care)
Resources are defined as any asset that can be utilized to produce income
or cash payments.
There are numerous rules as well as gifting look back provisions that define
what a resource is and is not.
Some important assets that aren't required to be counted as resources are
- a personal residence,
- a life insurance policy with less than $1,500 cash value,
- a prepaid funeral and burial plan and
- a car (if necessary for transportation and care).
If the recipient is married, the spouse at home keeps the residence and a
vehicle worth any value.
These excluded assets do not count against the eligibility of someone
applying for Medicaid.
If the recipient is single but plans on returning home, the residence in most
states is not included but is excluded for purposes of eligibility.
The house would however, be subject to lien recovery at the death of
the recipient.
Any rental income must be applied towards the care of the recipient.
- An important rule change this year takes into account the market value
of the home.
- If the home is worth more than $500,000 it prevents any single person
from qualifying for Medicaid.
- This penalty does not apply if a spouse or dependent child is living in
the home In most states, money invested in an IRA, a 401(k) or any other
tax qualified account is not counted as a resource if the Medicaid recipient
is older than age 70 1/2.
- Mandatory withdrawals from these accounts are considered income and not
assets.
- It's possible these assets might be subject to recovery after the
death of the recipient or require assignment on tax qualified annuities.
- After meeting the resource and level of care (need for care assessment)
tests and qualifying for Medicaid, a recipient is required to share
Medicaid costs by contributing all of his or her income to the total cost of
care and Medicaid picks up the balance, if any.
- An allowance of $45 a month is added back in to provide monthly
personal care.
- Also, an allowance for medical costs and insurance premiums not covered
by Medicare is added back in.
Spousal Impoverishment Rules
There are special rules that apply to couples and prevent the healthy spouse
from being impoverished due to a lack of assets or income.
Regardless of who owns them, all assets are considered jointly owned by the
couple.
Assets are totaled and then split in half and a healthy spouse at home
keeps his or her half and the Medicaid applicant must spend down his or her half
until it is less than $2,000.
This money need not be spent on care but can be spent on any legitimate
purchase.
Tax qualified savings accounts under the rules above are not considered
assets.
If the total amount of assets are less than $20,328, the spouse
at home keeps the entire amount and does not have to split in half.
If the spouse at home gets more than $101,640 after the assets have been
split in half, that spouse can only keep $101,640 and all the rest of the
assets have to be spent down by the person applying for Medicaid.
- As an example, a couple owns $400,000 in resources.
- The spouse at home can only keep $$101,640 and the spouse applying for
Medicaid has to spend $298,360 less $2,000 before that spouse can qualify
for Medicaid.
- Incomes are not considered jointly owned and do not have to be split in
half.
- If John has $3,000 a month in income and Sarah has $800 a month, and
John applies for Medicaid, then John's entire $3,000 will go towards his
care and Sarah will presumably be left impoverished with only $800 a month.
- The reverse is also true if Sarah needs the care. John can keep his
$3,000 and the state must make up the difference between Sarah's $800 and
the cost of the nursing home.
- If John is applying for Medicaid, and in order to avoid complete
impoverishment of Sarah, (she only has $800 a month) the state will transfer
enough of John's income to bring Sarah's income up to $1,650 a month. This
is called the community spouse monthly income impoverishment allowance.
- For people receiving community waiver care there are additional
allowances. The asset and income allowances are adjusted each year for
inflation.
Gifting Rules
New rules adopted in 2006 require any gift or a
transfer-for-less-than-value within 60 months of a Medicaid community waiver or
nursing home application to be counted as a resource to the extent of the amount
of transfer. A transfer within 60 months from application is considered a gift
whether made outright or conveyed in a trust. It makes no difference.
- There is a new penalty associated with these transfers.
- Disregard what you have heard in the past about gifts and penalties.
- Here's how the new version works.
- Suppose Mary replaces her name with her daughter's name on the title of
Mary's residence with a net value of $280,000. Mary applies for Medicaid
59 months after the title transfer and one month shy of the look back limit.
Because she is inside the look back period, the gift of the house becomes
a transfer for less than value.
- Mary has less than $2,000 in resources and could qualify for Medicaid.
Medicaid will not pay a dime for Mary's care until the equivalent spend
down for her gift has been paid.
- In other words, the state considers the gift to be cash-in-hand that
should have been spent before Mary qualified for Medicaid assistance.
- This spend down requirement now becomes a penalty after the fact.
- The penalty is determined in months of care and is calculated by
dividing the amount of the gift by the state Medicaid rate which in this
example is $4,000 a month.
- Dividing the gift by the monthly rate yields 70 (almost 6 years) months
of penalty.
- From the date that Mary would have been approved for Medicaid someone
must pay for 70 months of her care before Medicaid will take over.
- Note in this case the penalty is longer than the look back period.
- With a large gift, penalty periods could last up to five to ten years or
more.
- If Mary applied for Medicaid 60 months and one day after making the gift
there would be no penalty.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Medicaid Recovery Medicaid recovery rules were initiated by Congress in 1993.
After the death of the Medicaid recipient, Medicaid has a claim against the
home that was previously excluded for eligibility. The claim is in the amount
that Medicaid paid for the recipient's care.
In some states a lien against the property, called a TEFRA lien, can be
filed in anticipation of Medicaid's cost.
Not all states file a TEFRA lien but typically file a debtor lien after the
death. As a matter of policy, some states do not make a claim against the
property if the surviving spouse is living in the house. The debt is forgiven.
This is only current policy since rules allow the state to initiate recovery
through a lien on the property.
There are also rules allowing the family to request a hardship hearing if
recovery puts a burden on the family and the state also has authority to waive
recovery on homes worth less than a certain dollar amount.
Common rumor among professionals who do Medicaid planning is that Medicaid
recovery in many states is more "bark than bite". Numerous articles and studies
indicate that states do an extremely poor job of recovering money from assets
that should be subject to recovery.
There is a suspicion that some property transferring in trusts or through
joint tenancy may be escaping from recovery services.
Do not let these statements lull you into a false sense of security.
Continuing Medicaid budget deficits and a change in state leadership
could result in Medicaid becoming much more aggressive about recovering money it
can legally go after.
The first step would be changing state code allowing for TEFRA liens.
The use of such liens would preclude any transfer of property prior to
satisfaction of the lien.